An Indian rooftop decision
Solar vs Grid Electricity Planner
Compare rooftop solar with staying on grid electricity using your Indian DISCOM bill, free monthly units, subsidy, export credit and long-term upkeep.
Your bill and rooftop
Cash paid, bills avoided
You could spend ₹6,39,852 less by adding rooftop solar
Your solar spending is recovered through bill savings in year 6.
Planning estimate only. Actual slab billing, subsidy approval, generation and DISCOM settlement can differ.
Personalized Planning
Insights from your numbers
Your free-unit allowance matters
No free monthly units are applied. If your household receives a state benefit, entering it may materially lengthen payback.
Daytime use is the valuable part
At 55% self-consumption, the system directly serves 2,393 units in year one. Direct use avoids your retail rate; exports receive only the entered ₹3.00 per unit.
Test the vendor case
Reduce generation per kW, set export credit to ₹0 and shorten the horizon. If solar still leads, the decision relies less on favourable estimates.
Practical Meaning
What your rooftop changes
Bill before solar
Year-one grid-only bill: ₹31,200, including the entered fixed charge.
Bill after solar
Year-one residual bill: ₹6,188. Fixed charges remain.
Not backup power
This is an on-grid, no-battery model. Standard grid-tied solar generally switches off during an outage.
Understanding the decision
Let’s see the underlying logic
Free units reduce chargeable imports in both paths. Directly used solar reduces imports; remaining generation earns the entered export rate, capped at variable import charges. Generation degrades annually and the chosen replacement cost lands in its selected year.
| Year | Generation | Grid cumulative | Solar cumulative | Solar advantage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 4,350 units | ₹31,200 | ₹1,41,188 | −₹1,09,988 |
| 6 | 4,242 units | ₹2,05,430 | ₹1,95,325 | +₹10,104 |
| 12 | 4,117 units | ₹4,61,543 | ₹3,16,817 | +₹1,44,727 |
| 25 | 3,857 units | ₹12,59,402 | ₹6,19,550 | +₹6,39,852 |
Model boundary: one flat effective energy rate, one monthly free-unit allowance, constant annual household use and no financing or tax effects. It does not reproduce every state slab, duty, minimum bill, banking period or settlement rule.
Practical Guidance
Detailed India rooftop-solar FAQs
What does one electricity ‘unit’ mean in India?01
One unit on an Indian electricity bill is one kilowatt-hour (kWh). A 1 kW appliance running for one hour uses about one unit. Enter the average monthly units from recent DISCOM bills, preferably covering both summer and winter rather than relying on one unusual month.
How are free electricity units handled?02
Enter the units per month that your household receives free under a state or DISCOM scheme. The model applies that allowance to imported grid units in both paths before charging the editable per-unit tariff. Because free-unit schemes and eligibility can change, the calculator does not assume a state-specific allowance. Fixed charges are still included.
Can rooftop solar make my bill literally zero?03
Not necessarily. Fixed charges, meter charges, electricity duty, minimum bills, fuel surcharges and other DISCOM items may remain even if solar offsets energy charges. This model keeps your entered fixed monthly charge in both paths. It is a planning estimate, not a replica of a particular DISCOM bill.
Why can free units make solar payback slower?04
If your grid consumption already falls within a free-unit allowance, those units have no avoided energy charge. Solar first replaces electricity that may already be free, so its rupee saving can be much smaller than its physical generation. Entering the allowance explicitly prevents the model from valuing every solar unit at the full retail tariff.
What electricity tariff should I enter for a slab-based bill?05
Use an effective marginal rate for the units solar is likely to displace, not blindly the total bill divided by total units. If your bill crosses several slabs, inspect the energy-charge portion and test a lower and higher rate. Keep fixed charges in the separate field. The model intentionally avoids pretending one national tariff exists.
How should I estimate annual solar generation per kW?06
Use the vendor’s site-specific generation estimate after considering city, roof direction, tilt, shade, temperature, wiring and inverter losses. A broad India planning range may be useful for a first pass, but a shadow study and local generation guarantee are better. The default is only an editable illustration.
What is self-consumption?07
Self-consumption is the share of solar generation used in your home while it is being generated. Daytime loads such as pumps, refrigeration, work-from-home equipment and scheduled appliances can raise it. The rest is treated as export. This is not the same as the share of your total electricity demand met by solar.
How does the calculator value exported solar power?08
Exported units receive the export-credit rate you enter. To stay conservative, annual export credit is capped at that year’s variable import charge; the model does not create a cash payout or use credits to erase fixed charges. Actual net-metering, net-billing, banking and settlement rules are set by the state regulator and DISCOM.
What export rate should I use under net metering?09
Check your latest state electricity regulatory commission order, DISCOM rooftop-solar page or sanctioned agreement. Some arrangements offset imported units, while others credit exports at a separately determined rate. If you are uncertain, run a conservative case with ₹0 export value and another with the documented rate.
How is the PM Surya Ghar subsidy included?10
Enter only the central or state assistance you reasonably expect to receive, based on the current portal, your residential eligibility, sanctioned capacity and completed DISCOM process. The default ₹78,000 is an illustration commonly associated with a qualifying 3 kW residential system under published PM Surya Ghar CFA rates; it is not guaranteed and should be replaced with your approved amount.
Should the system quote include GST, net meter and approvals?11
Enter the complete amount you must fund before subsidy: modules, inverter, structure, wiring, earthing, lightning protection, installation, taxes, bidirectional meter or testing fees where charged, and any roof-strengthening work. Confirm inclusions in writing because vendor quote formats vary.
Does the model include a battery?12
No. It models an on-grid residential rooftop system without battery storage. A battery changes capital cost, replacement cost, usable solar energy, backup availability and round-trip losses. Do not add a battery quote to this model unless you also adjust the generation and cost assumptions separately.
Will ordinary rooftop solar work during a power cut?13
Usually not. A standard grid-tied inverter must disconnect during an outage for anti-islanding safety, even in bright sunlight. Backup requires compatible hybrid equipment and storage or another approved arrangement. Financial savings and outage resilience are different decisions.
What are degradation and inverter replacement assumptions?14
Panel output generally changes over time, so the model reduces annual generation by your degradation input. It also lets you place one inverter replacement in a chosen year. Use the module performance warranty, inverter warranty and vendor service terms for your case; warranty coverage and actual replacement timing can differ.
Does maintenance include panel cleaning?15
Use the annual maintenance field for cleaning, inspection, minor repairs, monitoring or an AMC that you expect to pay. Water availability, dust, bird droppings, access safety and local labour affect cleaning cost and frequency. The model holds this rupee amount constant, so increase it if you want a more conservative long-term case.
How is payback calculated?16
Payback is the first whole year when cumulative grid-only bills equal or exceed the solar path’s net upfront cost plus solar-era grid bills, maintenance and any inverter replacement. It is simple cash payback: no loan interest, income-tax effect, discount rate or resale value is included.
Should I finance rooftop solar with a loan?17
This model assumes you pay the net upfront cost from cash. For a loan, compare EMIs, processing fees, interest, subsidy timing and any collateral or insurance conditions against monthly bill savings. A system can have a positive long-term saving while still creating a difficult near-term cash-flow gap.
What should I verify before choosing a vendor?18
Verify portal and DISCOM eligibility, sanctioned load, feasible capacity, roof rights and structural condition; request generation assumptions, equipment makes and model numbers, ALMM/DCR compliance where applicable, warranties, workmanship cover, approvals, meter scope, service response and a line-item quote. Do not treat the calculator’s outcome as vendor due diligence.
Your next step
Look further
Your last 12 months of units, sanctioned load and available shadow-free roof area. Ask for a generation estimate and line-item quote.
Maintained and verified by the Calculated Wisdom Financial Research Team · Reviewed 29 Aug 2026